When the opportunity to read this book for PBN came along, I snagged it. Not because my oldest child is a “tween”, but maybe because I felt my teen years were so conflicted and I came out of it all OK in spite of my parents, not because of them. That disregard and feeling last place in my own family has been the driving force in many of the parenting decisions I make now.I think the first thing of note to identify about The Teen Whisperer is that it isn’t all psychobabbly. Yes, that is a NEW WORD I just made up! Sure, he’s a licensed counselor who has worked with troubled teens for over a decade. But, he, as the author, makes it clear that in his own estimation he’s just a guy who seems to have a way with teenagers and the therapist stuff is all secondary. I mean, anybody familiar with farm and/or ranch life understands his “everyman” references to himself. It is humbling and backbreaking work that lends itself to developing a kid with those kind of responsibilities to have a no-nonsense outlook on life.
Little did I know when the time came to read and re-read portions of this book, so many sections would apply to my own life as its happening. Right now, as of this review, we have an appointment with my oldest son’s teacher regarding the four F’s (you read that right) he is getting right now in school. This is a kid who, until his grades slipped, was in the gifted program. He scores in the crazy smart percentages on state and national standardized tests. He’s a talented artist who also plays piano and has dreams to one day be an architect. And he also seems a little Jekyl-Hyde lately where he’s still his usual helpful self in one moment then a complaining punk in the next. It’s enough to make hubby and I want to tear our hair out.
Aren’t we super duper awesome parents?? So supportive, so intensely desiring to see our children succeed, be happy, do well?? Yeah, so were all the parents of the kids used as examples in the book. By my count, unless I’m forgetting one, the kids counseled in the book were the children of hard-working, well-intentioned parents for the most part.
The Teen Whisperer isn’t about casting blame on parents. It’s not about casting blame on the teens, though he does expect teens to take responsibility for their actions. The entire book is a systematic way of breaking down the major things that influence a teens life and how those things affect the choices, good or bad, that they make.
I have a group of friends of which I am one of the younger parents. As in, my kids are younger and many of them are in or have finished with their kids’ teen years. As my best friend told me once after enduring a toddler screaming fit that left me with frazzled nerves, “Little kids, little problems. Big kids, big problems”. I now understand what she meant, as I’d do just about anything to be back at a time when if my son was being naughty, I took away his beloved Thomas trains. Now, he’s flunking 6th grade and I feel very helpless.
The Teen Whisperer is a straightforward and common sense approach with professional validation. I appreciated his lack of BS, I tend to avoid self-help or psychology based texts like the plague. A lot of times, I think the authors of those kind of books come off horrifically pompous and kind of “I’m an expert, therefore I know everything” and I don’t usually like that. Linderman’s “aww shucks” approach makes the book easier to accept as something you might actually apply to your own parenting experiences.
He gets a little repetitive, but then again, sometimes it takes people multiple mentions for the message to be received. Additionally, if you are not a text or self-help book reader and if you don’t have teens, this probably doesn’t have a lot to offer. As a mother of four would-be teens, sooner rather than later, there were many helpful reminders as to staying on track in the parenting department. Bottom line: many problems are totally avoidable by raising kids with healthy self-esteem. Easier said than done, but it never hurts to hear the reminder.
As for my “tween”, we’ll make it through. Hubby and I are meeting with his teacher today to identify what is happening and how to help him through what is clearly a problematic time manifesting itself in his grades. But as long as there are people out there, like Linderman, who deeply care for and help kids, it makes me feel a little less overwhelmed.
Sunshine's Rating:












6 comments:
wow that is a lot to deal with. Having been through a trobuled sixth grade year with my firstborn I can relate. He didn't fail anything but he didn't come by graduating from 6th grade easily. The counselors and teachers all said it is so tough for some kids to transition from easy crayon and marker, one-teacher elementary to different classes, teachers, lockers and taking showers at school. It'll work out and he'll get back on track. Although I would tend to agree with your friend's assessment (Big kid, big problems) I'm keeping my fingers crossed! Good review by the way.
Although my oldest is only 7, I am completely terrified of his teens. And even more so for my daughter's teen years (she's almost 5.) I think I might get this book as a pre-emptive strike. Great review Sonia!
what is this place? Another blog? Oh hon. Where have I been?
this post is so good. I am going to put this blog up in my browser. What is that other place?
Man. I operate in a world of such confusion. please forgive me.
by: Maia Szalavitz
"Teen Whisperer or Teen Tormentor: As Congress Takes On Troubled Teen Programs, Times Inadvertently Plugs One
Posted October 23, 2007 | 03:35 PM (EST)
While I've gotta give The New York Times kudos for its strong editorial "When Tough Love is Too Tough," calling for greater oversight of the "troubled teen" residential industry, I must simultaneously take them to task for running a glowing review of a book by a counselor who worked for 10 years for one of the most notorious organizations in that business.
Mike Linderman, author of The Teen Whisperer served as "clinical director" of Spring Creek Lodge, a Montana program linked with the infamous World Wide Association of Specialty Programs and Schools (WWASP, also called WWASPS).
Calling Linderman "brusquely compassionate," the Times Styles section approvingly cited him for that work. But it failed to even mention the history of serious abuse allegations and lawsuits involving Spring Creek Lodge -- many of which include the decade in which Linderman worked there.
Take this 2003 Times story, headlined "Program to Help Troubled Youths Has Troubles of Its Own." In it, investigative reporter Tim Weiner notes that "some children and parents call [Spring Creek Lodge] physically and psychologically brutal." He goes on to detail stories of teens locked in solitary confinement for months [photo of the claustrophic isolation room known as "the Hobbit" at Spring Creek is here], fed only beans and bananas. Linderman worked at Spring Creek at the time and apparently was employed by the program until some time in 2006.
Weiner quotes the mother of one teen, Michele Ziperovich, saying "He came out 35 pounds lighter, acting like a zombie. When he came back, he was worse, far worse." Weiner also reports that former employees have corroborated the teens' stories and that one was arrested for sexually assaulting teens in the isolation room.
In 2005, a Spring Creek staffer shot a man seven times and then killed himself. And in 2006, Spring Creek was sued after a teenage girl committed suicide there-- the suit says that the facility "was not designed or operated to provide quality or even adequate care" and that its employees "planned and operated Spring Creek Lodge Academy in such a manner that physical, educational, mental or emotional harm was consistently and foreseeably caused to the children at Spring Creek."
The Times mentions nothing of this controversy -- essentially allowing the author to claim that The New York Times endorses his book and by association, Spring Creek Lodge.
Nor does the review inform readers that when Linderman worked at Spring Creek, it was affiliated with WWASP, which has had no fewer than eight programs shuttered following abuse allegations. In Mexico, police filmed kids chained in outdoor dog cages at one program -- a program to which kids at Spring Creek were often sent if they didn't behave.
Spring Creek Lodge is currently the subject of a large class action suit -- with over 100 plaintiffs claiming serious human rights violations occurred there and at other WWASP programs.
I think parents considering taking advice from the "Teen Whisperer" might want to know that he has been accused as well of being a "Teen Tormentor" and party to institutionalized child abuse.
And we wonder why people distrust the media...
boarding schools for adolescents provide educational seminars and workshops specially made for struggling youths and adults. These help in character building increase in confidence, reliability, honesty and integrity in very caring and nursing residential environment.
http://www.strugglingteen.net
The boarding school is one of the wonderful places for troubled teens in which they are offering lots of innovative and educative programs for kids. It helps them to improve their capability and quality, and also enhance the skills of their students.
http://www.teenageproblems.net/
Post a Comment